diff --git a/src/controllers/tanksController.js b/src/controllers/tanksController.js
index e53dc116..e3819a28 100644
--- a/src/controllers/tanksController.js
+++ b/src/controllers/tanksController.js
@@ -1203,16 +1203,30 @@ exports.consumption = async (request, reply) => {
 
       let consumption;
 
-const isSameTime = start.getTime() === end.getTime();
-const isToday = moment(start).isSame(moment(), 'day');
 
-if (isSameTime && !isToday) {
-  // Same date & time and NOT today => use only records
+
+      const isSameTime = start.getTime() === end.getTime();
+const isEndToday = moment(end).isSame(moment(), 'day');
+
+if (isSameTime || !isEndToday) {
+  // If single timestamp OR end is not today, only use records
   consumption = total_consumption_from_records;
 } else {
-  // Normal case => use full calculation
+  // If end is today, add real-time values
   consumption = (waterlevel_at_midnight + total_water_added_from_midnight) - waterlevel + total_consumption_from_records;
 }
+
+
+// const isSameTime = start.getTime() === end.getTime();
+// const isToday = moment(start).isSame(moment(), 'day');
+
+// if (isSameTime && !isToday) {
+//   // Same date & time and NOT today => use only records
+//   consumption = total_consumption_from_records;
+// } else {
+//   // Normal case => use full calculation
+//   consumption = (waterlevel_at_midnight + total_water_added_from_midnight) - waterlevel + total_consumption_from_records;
+// }
      
       // Add to the total consumption and capacities based on water type
       if (tank.typeOfWater === "bore" || tank.typeOfWater === "Bore Water") {